Zone 0 Isn't Law Yet. I Got That Wrong
In August I told Peninsula owners the Zone 0 rules had taken effect. The Board pulled the filing on September 8. There is no effective date and no compliance clock.
In August I published a post titled "Zone 0 Just Became Law." That was wrong, and if you acted on it, I owe you a correction rather than a quiet edit.
The short version: the Board of Forestry adopted the rules, the filing never cleared the Office of Administrative Law, and the Board withdrew it. There is no statewide Zone 0 regulation in force today, no effective date, and no compliance clock running against your property.
What I Told You In August
That the Board had approved the first Zone 0 defensible space regulations in the country on August 19, that they were expected to take effect around the end of September, and that existing homes faced a phase-in with specific obligations at the three and five year marks.
The first part was right. The Board did adopt the rules on August 19, unanimously. Everything after that was me reading a Board vote as the end of the process when it was the middle of one.
What Happened Instead
The Board filed the package with the Office of Administrative Law on August 28 as an emergency regulation. OAL ran its five-day public comment window, which closed September 2.
Then on September 8, before OAL ruled, the Board withdrew the filing. The package is listed under OAL file number 2026-0828-03E as withdrawn on that date. The Board has characterized the move as procedural, a chance to make technical edits and answer OAL's questions before refiling.
As of today it has not been refiled. The Board's own page says it continues to work with OAL on a final review of the Zone 0 rule package, with an update expected when that review is complete and when the Secretary of State publishes the final regulation.
That last clause is the part I should have understood in August. A Board vote adopts language. OAL approval and filing with the Secretary of State are what make it operative. Until that happens there is nothing to comply with.
Where That Leaves You
No deadline is running. If a contractor, landscaper, or vendor has quoted you work on the basis of a September or October compliance date, that date does not exist, and you should be skeptical of anyone still selling against it. There has been a fair amount of that this fall.
What has not changed is your existing obligation. California's longstanding defensible space law still applies, and so does whatever your local fire agency enforces. Woodside, Portola Valley, and the hill parcels above Los Altos Hills were in a high fire hazard severity zone before any of this and still are. Zone 0 would tighten the first five feet; it would not create your duty from nothing.
What It Will Require If It Lands
The adopted language is public, so the substance is worth knowing even while the status is unsettled. Zone 0 is an ember-resistant band extending roughly five feet from a qualifying structure, or to the property line if that is closer.
The core of it: combustible mulch, wood chips, leaves, needles and bark come out, with narrow temporary exceptions. Roofs and gutters stay clear. Vegetation and combustibles come out from under decks, balconies, pergolas and stairs. No firewood stored in the zone. Dead and dying branches and ladder fuels removed, chimney and eave separation maintained, vegetation kept away from vents and other vulnerable openings.
Fencing is the detail most owners miss. Combustible fences and gates could not be attached to a qualifying structure, new combustible fencing would be prohibited within the zone, and where fencing attaches or nearly attaches there would generally need to be a five-foot noncombustible span. Outbuildings under 120 square feet would be allowed inside the zone only if entirely noncombustible.
Local agencies in local responsibility areas could adopt alternative practices by ordinance, but only with a finding of at least substantially similar practical effect, and local rules may be stricter than the state floor.
The Phase-In Is Slower Than I Described
This is where my August post was most misleading, so it is worth being precise.
For new structures, the requirements would be delayed until the Board updates and posts its fuels-management guidance, which may take up to a year after adoption. For existing structures, the obligations that already exist under prior law would apply immediately once the rules take effect: clearing roofs and gutters, keeping firewood out of the zone, removing dead and dying branches, maintaining chimney clearance.
The rest, meaning the combustible-material, vegetation, fencing and outbuilding requirements, would phase in over roughly three to five years depending on whether the property sits in a local or state responsibility area and whether an implementation schedule is adopted. There is also a statutory layer setting existing-structure requirements to begin three years after the new-structure effective date.
All of those clocks start from an effective date that does not yet exist. Anyone calculating your deadline today is calculating from a date nobody has.
Why I'd Still Do The Work
Having spent this whole post explaining that nothing is required, here is the part that has not changed.
The five feet nearest a structure is where a survivable fire becomes a total loss. That was true before the Board voted and it will be true if the rule never finalizes. The cheapest items on the list, pulling bark mulch off the foundation and keeping the gutters clear, cost almost nothing and are the ones that matter most.
The insurance argument also stands on its own. The FAIR Plan's 29.1% average increase took effect on October 15, with the wildfire component driving most of it, and documented mitigation is what gets a Peninsula property back into the admitted market. No carrier has promised a discount for Zone 0 compliance specifically, and I am not going to pretend otherwise. But a file with dated photographs and vendor invoices is worth having in front of an underwriter deciding whether to write you at all.
So my advice is the same as it was in August, for different reasons. Do the work because it protects the house and helps the insurance conversation, not because a deadline is coming. And if you are handling it on a leased estate, the lease allocation question is still worth settling at renewal, since your tenant is the one who will stack firewood against the wall in November.
On Getting It Wrong
I write these from primary sources and I still managed to turn a regulatory adoption into a law that had not passed. The failure was treating a Board vote as the finish line when California rulemaking has two more steps after it.
I have corrected the August post and the September forecast that repeated the error. If you made a decision on the strength of either, I would rather hear about it than not.
If you own a Peninsula estate and want a straight read on your wildfire exposure, your insurance stack, or what your lease should say about any of it, schedule a confidential consultation. We manage properties across Woodside, Portola Valley, Atherton, and Los Altos Hills.
Sources
- California Board of Forestry Adopts Emergency "Zone 0" Regulations Under AB 3074 — Best Best & Krieger LLP
- Defensible Space Zones 0, 1 and 2 — California Board of Forestry and Fire Protection
- Zone 0 Regulations Withdrawn from OAL Review: What Happens Next? — Wildfire Los Angeles
- Notice of Proposed Emergency Action, Zone 0 Defensible Space — California Board of Forestry and Fire Protection
- California Office of Administrative Law — State of California
- Defensible Space — CAL FIRE
Considering private management?
Schedule a confidential conversation to discuss your residence.
Schedule a Consultation