The Emergency Rent Cap Now Covers Your Long Lease
Multi-year leases used to sit outside California's 10% price-gouging cap after an emergency declaration. From January 1 they don't. What that means for a Peninsula renewal.
There's a provision in California's price-gouging law that most Peninsula estate owners have never had to think about, because their leases sat outside it. From January 1 they won't.
What Changed
Penal Code 396 is the statute that restricts price increases after a state or local emergency declaration. For rental housing, it generally bars raising the price by more than 10% once a covered declaration is in effect.
Until now, the definition of covered housing excluded rentals with an initial lease term longer than one year. That exclusion did a lot of quiet work at the high end of the market, where two-year terms are normal and some estates lease for three.
SB 1365, from Senator Ben Allen, removes it. Governor Newsom signed the bill on September 30, the last day he could act, and from January 1, 2027 the restriction applies regardless of the initial lease term. A violation can be prosecuted as a misdemeanor, carrying up to a year in county jail, a fine of up to $10,000, or both.
Why This Lands on the Peninsula
Emergency declarations aren't exotic here. Wildfire events, atmospheric-river storms, and extended power shutoffs have all produced state or county declarations covering parts of the Bay Area in recent years, and once one is in place the price-gouging rule follows it.
So the scenario to plan for is unglamorous. Your two-year lease on a Woodside estate comes up for renewal in a month when Santa Clara or San Mateo County is under a declaration for a fire somewhere in the hills. You had planned a 12% increase because the market has moved and the comps support it. Under the new rule, that increase is restricted.
None of this freezes your rent forever. Declarations end. But the timing of a renewal is not something you fully control, and an owner who has been leasing estates for a decade without ever hitting the rule is about to discover it applies to them.
The Defenses Matter More Than the Cap
The law isn't absolute, and the exceptions are where the planning happens.
The first defense is that the tenant agreed to the increase before the declaration. That one is the most useful by far, because it means a rent schedule written into the lease at signing is on much firmer ground than a number you propose in month twenty-three.
The second covers increases tied to repair or addition costs beyond normal maintenance, incurred within the year before the declaration. It's narrower than it sounds. It applies only if the housing was rented, advertised, or offered for rent when those costs were incurred, or if you can show that within that year you intended to offer it for rent within six months of the work. A kitchen remodel you did two years ago doesn't qualify.
What I'd Change in the Lease
Write the escalator in at signing. If you expect the second year of a two-year lease to run higher, state the number or the formula now, agreed by the tenant, rather than negotiating it at renewal. A schedule agreed before any declaration is exactly what the first defense protects.
I'd do this anyway, because a stated escalator makes the renewal conversation shorter and less adversarial. But the new rule turns it from a nice-to-have into the thing that keeps your increase out of a criminal statute.
Document capital work with dates and invoices. If you're planning a significant improvement on a leased property, keep the paper trail that shows when the cost was incurred and that the property was being offered for rent at the time. That's the second defense, and you can only use it if you can prove it.
And stop treating renewal pricing as a single number you decide in month twenty-two. I've written about how I price luxury renewals around retention rather than squeezing, and this is one more reason to settle the path early. It belongs in the same review as the clauses I don't sign without.
What It Doesn't Do
It isn't rent control. Outside a declared emergency, nothing here limits what you charge, and the Tenant Protection Act's separate cap doesn't reach most single-family estates owned by individuals anyway.
It doesn't touch the rent already in effect. The restriction is on increases after a declaration, not on the lease you signed last spring.
And it doesn't apply in normal months. The point is narrow: the rule that already constrained one-year leases during an emergency now constrains yours too.
The Practical Version
Look at every lease you have renewing in 2027 and ask whether the second-year rent is written down. If it isn't, the next lease you sign should fix that.
Then think about your insurance and fire posture in the same breath, because the event that triggers a declaration is the same event that drives your FAIR Plan premium. Peninsula owners tend to treat the lease, the insurance, and the wildfire question as three separate files. From January the law treats them as connected.
Want your lease and renewal schedule reviewed against the new rule before your next signing? Schedule a confidential consultation. We manage estates across Atherton, Woodside, Portola Valley, Palo Alto, and Los Altos Hills.
Sources
- Governor signs bill expanding emergency rent caps to long-term leases — California Apartment Association
- California Penal Code Section 396 — California Legislative Information
- SB 1365 bill information — California Legislative Information
- Price Gouging — California Attorney General
- Tenant Protection Act overview — California Courts Self-Help
Considering private management?
Schedule a confidential conversation to discuss your residence.
Schedule a Consultation